Lorne Gunter and Chris Varcoe join Brian Lilley to discuss what the Pacific Link announcement means, who pays and whether it sways Alberta's Oct. 19 referendum
Why should we believe that this is anything other than political positioning re the Referendum?
Carney's Liberal voter base does not care about pipelines because most of their income is derived from the government (that is, other taxpayers). They can afford to laugh at those who will lose if a pipeline does not go through.
Of course, support for secession will grow but then Ottawa is trying to institute speech controls too. Those who never think differently from government will have no problem with that.
Struck a chord here it seems. So much of our public discussion feels dishonest because so few want to discuss the fact Carney does not need to solve any problems in order to stay in power indefinitely in a situation that is grossly inequitable. That alone will promote growing disunity. The only reason it is not worse is that so many capable Canadians have left.
Yes before 2015 - companies would invest money to build things in Canada. Then we elected a Liberal government who decided we should be a central planned economy like China and the EU.
Yup and the noose closes a little tighter for socialism, government controlled companies and the taxpayer is stuck with costs. Come on people, stop this madness, it’s suicide for this nation. Yu are making the likes of Carney even richer with no return. Where is our free health care, zero taxes, etc like Saudi Arabia and maybe others.
Yes. That was Canadian governments selling our resources to global entities for the price of the infrastructure to deliver it. That is exactly how we got where we are.
It has to be on taxpayers cuz no one in their right mind would waste money on something that will be shut down as in Kinder Morgan who walked after spending millions for nothing. This is all 🐂💩. The Indigenous (they rule) will not allow it & Carney knows it.
I listened on my drive, and the podcast was even better than I had imagined it might have been.
I was really impressed how knowledgeable were the guests with respect to what this pipeline announcement means, and what it doesn’t mean.
I strongly recommend folks take a listen and learn more about approvals, consultation, our regulatory environment, and the extensive hurdles that are yet to be challenged in order to get this announcement to be anything more than just an announcement.
It is interesting that the Calgary Chamber of Commerce is once again being quoted as though it speaks for Calgary businesses, when fewer than 3% of Calgary businesses are Chamber members, according to an AI search. If journalists want to be taken seriously then use credible information.
So much of what is being thrown around right now is weak or incomplete. I honestly can't tell whether journalists are repeating it because they see an Alberta referendum as a threat to Canada—or because they genuinely believe the information they're reporting.
Most Chambers of Commerce are only one step above a weekly breakfast club where multi level marketers sell trinkets to each other. I laugh when they haul people like that out.
Carney has left all laws and regulations in place. He counts on some other groups blocking it. Pointing his finger away from himself. Buying 10 political years.
I’ll be long in the the ground and my kids/grandkids will be eating printed lab grown meat before we see a new pipeline. Carney & Smith are looking for votes. I’m still voting Option 2 to the AB referendum.
They are probably eating that without knowing what they are actually eating. Can you trust that restaurants are using these products already to cut costs and maintain lower prices? We were at a local restaurant a few weeks ago (we frequently go to once a week just to get out), I said to my husband, there's something funky with the boneless chicken cutlet, the texture is off and so is the taste. My daughter also noticed something off with the value packs sold at local chain grocery store
Alberta separation was never going to pass the first time out. I think people are missing the brilliance of the referendum to hold a referendum. Defeat on the first isn’t a defeat for separation, it’s an indication not enough ground work has been done. The conversation will continue, and will pick up speed as Carney’s vaporware promises are shown to be smoke and mirrors for his real agenda. Be of good cheer, the battle has only just begun.
Building things is tough signing paperwork or having media announcements is easy. The minister put in charge of this boondoggle is the same minister in charge of the failed trade negotiations, same minister who’s MPO has only got its first actual project of interest a full year after it was formed. They say shovels in the ground by 2027 hilarious and completed by 2032…hilarious. Never going to happen. The original TMX took only 2-3yrs to build at a cost of $1B in today’s dollars, the expansion took 12yrs at a cost of $34B, this one will probably take 20yrs at a cost of $75-$100B. Another negative ROI project.
The hope is that eventually Canadians will feel enough pain economically that they will see the writing and decide to vote for someone who will cut all this red tape and restrictions. Unfortunately that is not the case. Too many people live in their ideological bubbles, comfortable that the money will never run out. In the real world, Canada is a resource rich country that should make it as easy as possible for resources to be extracted and transported to customers. In essence that’s where the money comes from for all our lavish social programs.
Someone, please anyone needs to explain this to the population. First Nations, government workers, healthcare workers all these people need to understand that without resource extraction there is no money for you!!!
My observation is that while Carney makes announcements the US is actually breaking ground on multiple projects (semiconductor plant - Arizona,data centres-multiple states, revitalization of infrastructure projects-around their country, etc).
Talk is cheap until the lack of actual action leaves Canadian businesses closing, Canadians unemployed, homeless & hungry.
This guy is all talk! No building beyond imaginable speeds is happening, no free trade between provinces still.
Oh but he doubled the outrageous debt Trudeau left us, hasn’t remotely had a fraction of the homes he promised built, he plans to increase immigration when home building isn’t caught up and the medical systems across the country are failing .
Ever wonder what the the timeline will be between these announcements and when we see completion of said pipeline? Typically it takes between 7-9 years (based on most recent data) between announcing and completion.
So how is this really helping Canada? And why does the government have to pay for the entire process when it used to be a private endevour? What does that mean for the turn-around on investment for Canadians? Billions spent, and likely have to wait a decade to even see a smidge of return.
The West coat pipeline was dead before it was announced. There’s no way the socialist denizens in BC will approve its transit thru their province. Even the purportedly indigenous rent-seekers want no part of it. The whole scheme is just a bait-and-switch false-flag event cooked up by Clown-car Carney trying to keep Alberta from going independent. And keeping Alberta’s Equalization payment for Quebecistan & the eastern rent-seekers.
Why should we believe that this is anything other than political positioning re the Referendum?
Carney's Liberal voter base does not care about pipelines because most of their income is derived from the government (that is, other taxpayers). They can afford to laugh at those who will lose if a pipeline does not go through.
Of course, support for secession will grow but then Ottawa is trying to institute speech controls too. Those who never think differently from government will have no problem with that.
Those bastards!! AB LNG is clean, desirable and profitable. I personally don’t want to be freezing cold in Canada. 😓
Struck a chord here it seems. So much of our public discussion feels dishonest because so few want to discuss the fact Carney does not need to solve any problems in order to stay in power indefinitely in a situation that is grossly inequitable. That alone will promote growing disunity. The only reason it is not worse is that so many capable Canadians have left.
Yes. I want to leave. Canada isn’t Canada anymore. I don’t know what we are.
People who have talked to me about that are dismayed when they discover what they would have to do to leave.
Anyone remember the days when pipelines cost the taxpayers zero dollars?
Yes before 2015 - companies would invest money to build things in Canada. Then we elected a Liberal government who decided we should be a central planned economy like China and the EU.
"WE" does not include me!!!!! I did not vote for Mark J Carney, or his Liberal "VOTE ONLY" MPs
Yup and the noose closes a little tighter for socialism, government controlled companies and the taxpayer is stuck with costs. Come on people, stop this madness, it’s suicide for this nation. Yu are making the likes of Carney even richer with no return. Where is our free health care, zero taxes, etc like Saudi Arabia and maybe others.
Yes. That was Canadian governments selling our resources to global entities for the price of the infrastructure to deliver it. That is exactly how we got where we are.
Clever.
Private Investors will not take it on knowing Indigenous will shut it down.
It has to be on taxpayers cuz no one in their right mind would waste money on something that will be shut down as in Kinder Morgan who walked after spending millions for nothing. This is all 🐂💩. The Indigenous (they rule) will not allow it & Carney knows it.
I am looking forward to consuming this discussion as I drive home today.
I am pleased there are still a few journalists in this Country that neither eat out of Mark Carney’s hand, nor shine his shoes while on their knees.
Quick question? How long, arduous, and how difficult is it to plan and approve a pipeline expansion that is right beside an already existing line?
I listened on my drive, and the podcast was even better than I had imagined it might have been.
I was really impressed how knowledgeable were the guests with respect to what this pipeline announcement means, and what it doesn’t mean.
I strongly recommend folks take a listen and learn more about approvals, consultation, our regulatory environment, and the extensive hurdles that are yet to be challenged in order to get this announcement to be anything more than just an announcement.
That is precisely the right question to ask! This is insane. Full stop.
Oh long, very long Donald. That is in Carney years!!!
It’s not swaying my vote.
What. do you mean by your vote.
She lives in Alberta. Not changing my vote either. Nothing would.
It is interesting that the Calgary Chamber of Commerce is once again being quoted as though it speaks for Calgary businesses, when fewer than 3% of Calgary businesses are Chamber members, according to an AI search. If journalists want to be taken seriously then use credible information.
So much of what is being thrown around right now is weak or incomplete. I honestly can't tell whether journalists are repeating it because they see an Alberta referendum as a threat to Canada—or because they genuinely believe the information they're reporting.
Most Chambers of Commerce are only one step above a weekly breakfast club where multi level marketers sell trinkets to each other. I laugh when they haul people like that out.
Carney has left all laws and regulations in place. He counts on some other groups blocking it. Pointing his finger away from himself. Buying 10 political years.
I’ll be long in the the ground and my kids/grandkids will be eating printed lab grown meat before we see a new pipeline. Carney & Smith are looking for votes. I’m still voting Option 2 to the AB referendum.
They are probably eating that without knowing what they are actually eating. Can you trust that restaurants are using these products already to cut costs and maintain lower prices? We were at a local restaurant a few weeks ago (we frequently go to once a week just to get out), I said to my husband, there's something funky with the boneless chicken cutlet, the texture is off and so is the taste. My daughter also noticed something off with the value packs sold at local chain grocery store
Me too
More useless posturing from Carney. Bet he moves faster when the EU comes to Montreal ! Watch the giveaways then.
Alberta separation was never going to pass the first time out. I think people are missing the brilliance of the referendum to hold a referendum. Defeat on the first isn’t a defeat for separation, it’s an indication not enough ground work has been done. The conversation will continue, and will pick up speed as Carney’s vaporware promises are shown to be smoke and mirrors for his real agenda. Be of good cheer, the battle has only just begun.
Exactly! I will be voting yes to all questions. If you don’t you’re a moron.
Building things is tough signing paperwork or having media announcements is easy. The minister put in charge of this boondoggle is the same minister in charge of the failed trade negotiations, same minister who’s MPO has only got its first actual project of interest a full year after it was formed. They say shovels in the ground by 2027 hilarious and completed by 2032…hilarious. Never going to happen. The original TMX took only 2-3yrs to build at a cost of $1B in today’s dollars, the expansion took 12yrs at a cost of $34B, this one will probably take 20yrs at a cost of $75-$100B. Another negative ROI project.
The hope is that eventually Canadians will feel enough pain economically that they will see the writing and decide to vote for someone who will cut all this red tape and restrictions. Unfortunately that is not the case. Too many people live in their ideological bubbles, comfortable that the money will never run out. In the real world, Canada is a resource rich country that should make it as easy as possible for resources to be extracted and transported to customers. In essence that’s where the money comes from for all our lavish social programs.
Someone, please anyone needs to explain this to the population. First Nations, government workers, healthcare workers all these people need to understand that without resource extraction there is no money for you!!!
Exactly
Definitely more paperwork, nothing is going to be built in this country with con-man Carney.
My observation is that while Carney makes announcements the US is actually breaking ground on multiple projects (semiconductor plant - Arizona,data centres-multiple states, revitalization of infrastructure projects-around their country, etc).
Talk is cheap until the lack of actual action leaves Canadian businesses closing, Canadians unemployed, homeless & hungry.
This guy is all talk! No building beyond imaginable speeds is happening, no free trade between provinces still.
Oh but he doubled the outrageous debt Trudeau left us, hasn’t remotely had a fraction of the homes he promised built, he plans to increase immigration when home building isn’t caught up and the medical systems across the country are failing .
But Canadian taxpayers can afford it, right?
Ever wonder what the the timeline will be between these announcements and when we see completion of said pipeline? Typically it takes between 7-9 years (based on most recent data) between announcing and completion.
So how is this really helping Canada? And why does the government have to pay for the entire process when it used to be a private endevour? What does that mean for the turn-around on investment for Canadians? Billions spent, and likely have to wait a decade to even see a smidge of return.
Yep, we are becoming a socialist disaster like Venezuela.
All this PM has stated is that he has agreed to talk about it some more. But NO worries folks, the cheque is in the mail.
The West coat pipeline was dead before it was announced. There’s no way the socialist denizens in BC will approve its transit thru their province. Even the purportedly indigenous rent-seekers want no part of it. The whole scheme is just a bait-and-switch false-flag event cooked up by Clown-car Carney trying to keep Alberta from going independent. And keeping Alberta’s Equalization payment for Quebecistan & the eastern rent-seekers.
More Carney blather.
Instead of business stepping in with a viable build, we get the taxpayer version of cost overrun, delays and more native payoffs.
Likely just to influence the Alberta separation vote.